Tax chairman Lake blasted by leader of national tax reform group over cigarette plan


Gov. Butch Otter receivied a firsthand look at a natural gas well last week from representatives of Alta Mesa energy company.

House Revenue and Taxation Committee Chairman Dennis Lake, R-Blackfoot, is taking heat over his plans to allow a proposal to increase Idaho’s cigarette tax by as much as $1.50.

Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, a Washington, D.C.-based flat-tax advocacy group, said that the Idaho state government, which could face a budget gap between $200 million and $400 million in fiscal year 2012, needs to live within its means and forgo any planned tax increases.

“The Idaho legislature should not be looking at any tax increases as a way to plug their budget.  Just as the hardworking people of Idaho have to live within their means, the state needs to learn to do the same while rejecting any kind of tax increase,” wrote Norquist.  “This 2010 election cycle spoke loud and clear against tax hikes and excessive spending. Taking tax increases off the table and looking to spending cuts is the answer to Idaho’s budget problem.”

Norquist also blasted Lake for the Blackfoot Republican’s notion that the cigarette tax increase proposal is about promoting good health, not raising revenue.

“It is naïve to think that a tax increase is not about raising revenue, especially when Idaho is facing an unbalanced budget problem to the tune of up to $400 million. Of course this tax increase is about raising revenue,” said Norquist. “When cigarette taxes are raised to prop up government spending levels, they don’t work. Cigarette tax revenue declines over time, making the tax hike a placeholder tax to be replaced with taxes on other behavior and/or products at a later date.”

When asked about the Norquist’s comments, Lake seemed unbothered.  “That’s OK,” he said.  “They have their opinion and we have ours.  This isn’t being done to raise revenue, it’s being done to protect public health and, in particular, the health of young people.”

For evidence that the bill isn’t a revenue-centered project, he points to the idea’s backers, a consortium of pro-health groups.  “What do they care about revenues?” asked Lake.  “They are more interested in helping people.”

Norquist’s argument isn’t completely solid, at least with respect to the message voters sent to Idaho’s state senators and representatives regarding cigarette tax increases.  While it is true that every lawmaker who voted for massive cuts to state departments and public schools in the 2010 session won re-election Nov. 2, polling data released by Moore Information, an independent Portland-based polling firm, in mid-October suggests that Idahoans might favor boosting cigarette taxes to raise revenue for state programs.

The poll, conducted Oct. 16 and 17 found that 73 percent of 500 Gem State residents queried support a $1.50 hike in the cigarette tax to preserve funding for Medicaid, and youth smoking prevention and smoking-cessation programs.

Idaho’s tax on cigarettes is the eighth-lowest in the nation at 57 cents per pack and the lowest in the Inland Northwest.  The nationwide average sits at $1.45 per pack in state taxes.  According to 2008 numbers released in the Wall Street Journal, about 17 percent of Idaho adults smoke.

Studies suggest that if Idaho’s tax rate is increased by $1.00, as many as 6,200 Idahoans would quit smoking.  The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids (TBF), a group dedicated to developing policy options that prevent youngsters from taking up smoking, also says that the state would likely save upward of $230 million in health care costs due to lower smoking rates.

Some estimates forecast that Idaho would bring in an additional $46 million in tax revenue if the tax is hiked by $1.00, while other predicts say a $1.50 increase would hike tax revenues by $52 million.  Those numbers account for the anticipated decline in smoking rates.  Lake said he doesn’t believe the $1.50 plan will fly with his committee members, but instead believes lawmakers might agree on a lower figure.

Comments

comments

Image:
/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/auditorium.jpg, /wp-content/uploads/2010/10/auditorium.jpg
Image Caption:
The Idaho Legislature will consider hiking the cost of cigarettes in 2011, The Idaho Legislature will consider hiking the cost of cigarettes in 2011
Tagged under

10 Comments

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Tax chairman Lake blasted by leader of national tax reform group over cigarette plan « Idaho Reporter -- Topsy.com

  2. JC

    Smokers make themselves targets, since, after all, they contribute a huge portion to state and federal healthcare costs and productivity losses that the rest of us nonsmokers pay for in taxes. Seems pretty righteous to me.

  3. jsidney

    If we’re going to tax whatever costs the states the most, TAX CHILDREN! The states squander immense amounts of our tax money on children. Slap a tax on those fornicating parents who beggar the state with their excess produce.

    Tax children, not tobacco.

  4. find4more

    To JC– “righteous” perhaps, but not right. Arkansas’s experience backs what Norquist says:

    http://arkansasnews.com/2010/12/02/group-says-some-health-programs-still-not-funded-by-tobacco-tax/

    It is always claimed that the money will go to healthcare, and it NEVER does. It almost always goes to boondogle entitlements that the general population doesn’t want to pay higher taxes for…but will have to when the cigarette money dries up. The tax addiction for Lake is stronger than a nicotine addiction. I read a news story today that New York City’s Bloomberg is suing a Washington State indian reservation for selling cigarettes to New Yorkers. He needs to feed his voracious tax fix, because NYC’s cigarette taxes are the highest in the country, creating a $1 billion a year black market for cigarettes in New York State alone.

    Heartland Institute policy paper, “Top Ten Reasons Not To Raise Tobacco Taxes” also supports Norquist:

    http://www.heartland.org/full/25987/Research_Commentary_Top_Ten_Reasons_Not_to_Raise_

  5. Tommy

    If the Legislature needs more money I suggest they give up all perks they now enjoy at taxpayers expense. I’m required BY LAW to stay within my budget, the lawmakers should be required to do the same. I have to pay property taxes 5 days before Christmas which means no presents for the family. I can’t simply run around imposing a Christmas tax on my neighbors to pay for Christmas so why should they raise taxes because they skipped economics class in college. Gimme, gimme, gimme, spend, spend, spend. The people spoke very loudly this past November 2nd. We’re tired of every cent being sucked out of our wallets. And still they don’t listen! Well…there will be coal in some peoples stockings this year…better hope Santa doesn’t smoke.

  6. find4more

    I don’t know why states considering jacking up cigarette taxes don’t look at news articles appearing in states that have done that already to the Nth degree. Here’s two New York City Post articles from not so long ago. The “comments” sections are even more enlightening than the articles:

    http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/it_pays_to_cheat_2RVxXiR0GhL7ZZSEDTxc9H?listcomments=true#comments

    http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/burned_by_bootleg_smokes_IqtVTHYSTsWW6KcabOliRO

  7. PattyAnn

    I think they need to tax what come from your car tailpipe it is fare more dangerous then a person who is smoking ..you can put a 25 smokers in a closed garage and you will not die from the smoking ..but 1 car with the motor running will kill all 25 people ..so think about that !……The big polluter is the cars, trucks , buses and your big SUVs , but yet I see nobody slowing down on there useless driving !!!or flying !There is no such truth to second hand smoke ..it was just away to get none smokers to fear something..because if that where true ..there would be no Baby Boomers !!

  8. Dan

    in the future i envision a cigarette cartel and people growing tobacco in closets! FBI will raid houses and ruin families! Life in prison will be a mandatory sentence!

    this is going way to far

63°F

Boise

Fair

Humidity 40%

Wind 12 mph

  • 24 Jul 201479°F54°F
  • 25 Jul 201486°F59°F